30
Aniston and Sandler have a goofy, relaxed rapport that is often amusing despite the film’s best efforts to smother any sign of verve.
What are people saying?
What are critics saying?
50
Murder Mystery feels as shamelessly gaudy as paste jewelry — a trinket for nights that aspire to nothing more exotic than a pizza — but Aniston sparkles like the real deal.
25
The Globe and Mail (Toronto) by Barry Hertz
The new movie is dumb, pointless and completely bereft of laughs. It wastes a talented cast and all of your time. Worst of all, though, it is unconscionably lazy, starting with its generic title (again, who is naming these things?) and ending with its shrug-of-the-shoulders climax.
60
A surprisingly nimble summer comedy that finds both Aniston and Sandler at their most charming.
50
RogerEbert.com by Brian Tallerico
With competent but unspectacular direction from Kyle Newacheck (“Game Over, Man!”) and an entertaining supporting cast, Murder Mystery does just enough to keep audiences engaged until its goofy mystery is solved.
58
The A.V. Club by Ignatiy Vishnevetsky
The mystery itself is rote and, despite its jokey foreshadowing and its constant winks to the audience, never smart enough to really work as a genre parody. Instead, the movie just breezes along on the strength of Aniston and Sandler’s easygoing rapport.
30
The Hollywood Reporter by John DeFore
A tale as generic, and as dull, as its title.
30
Los Angeles Times by Justin Chang
One could imagine a context in which some of this belabored mayhem might be funny, maybe a dinner-theater stage with lots of booze and a strong audience-participation element. Seen from the vantage of your living room, however, the spectacle of Aniston and Sandler bumbling their way through one strained, busy set-piece after another becomes a deflating, even depressing experience.
58
The movie proves a cheery enough diversion, during a summer movie season leaden with underwhelming blockbuster offerings.
25
Even with a title this generic, there’s less to Murder Mystery than meets the eye.