Time by Judy Berman

As it touches on hotly debated topics, from trans identity to the troubled teen industry, the show distinguishes itself by contextualizing and complicating them rather than devolving into polemic.

Variety by Aramide Tinubu

Amid an endlessly captivating cast and a compelling plot that never quite moves in the direction the viewers might expect, “Wayward” is a thrilling watch.

Decider by Joel Keller

Wayward has two very compelling lead performances from Martin and Collette, and a good balance between the dark and the darkly funny.

The Telegraph by Anita Singh

The show is elevated by Martin, who is best known as a comedian but fully commits to a serious role. Alex is an immensely likeable character, earnest and empathetic, and gets the audience fully onside.

The Independent by Helen Coffey

The concept is genuinely well executed, with characters who hold their own and enough well-timed twists to keep viewers hooked.

The Guardian by Lucy Mangan

Less could have been more, but the warmth and intelligence that Martin as an actor and writer (along with others, in the latter case) brings to the endeavour means it cannot help but endear itself to the viewer.

The Playlist by Brian Farvour

It’s ultimately a show about an unsettling town with a dangerous secret, another in a long lineage of precursors that seem content with drawing from the same communal pot and doing little to alter the recipe. Were one to venture into the world of ‘Wayward,’ the greatest takeaways come from its cast, characters, and outstanding screenplay, with enough gas left in the tank by the end to pique the right amount of curiosity into what the future might hold.

The A.V. Club by Saloni Gajjar

The found-family aspect becomes the show’s beating heart. So even though it doesn’t put a fresh spin on the thriller, Martin’s series packs an emotional punch that’s hard to shake off.

TV Guide by Gavia Baker-Whitelaw

Wayward sticks close to some familiar beats of the genre but thrives on its well-realized characters — most obviously with Mae Martin's socially awkward Alex and the relatable ensemble cast of Tall Pines students.

Paste Magazine by Lacy Baugher

While its conclusion is more frustrating than you might expect, Wayward’s stellar performances and propulsive pacing make the journey worth more than the destination.