TV Guide by Kaitlin Thomas

The new episodes ... are more of the same enthusiastically entertaining adventures we've come to expect from [Wynonna Earp]. And they're coming at exactly the right time.

Collider by Allison Keene

The premiere episode jumps into the action and atmosphere immediately, though it takes a little while for the show settle in to what is a very fast-paced story. But by the second episode, it’s already found its rhythm.

Variety by Maureen Ryan

The first four episodes of Season 2 are focused and fun.

The Detroit News by Tom Long

It’s all a bit fuzzy, but then it’s all in good fun. Television has plenty of room for strong female characters.

The A.V. Club by Genevieve Valentine

If it all sounds a little by-the-numbers, it is. But part of the fun of both Westerns and pulp revenge stories is setting up the tropes to play with them later, so Wynonna Earp could just be getting a few things out of the way before the shenanigans really get started.

The Hollywood Reporter by Daniel Fienberg

With the important caveat that Wynonna Earp, premiering on Syfy on Friday (April 1), isn't as sharp, funny, thematically rich and consistently well-cast as Buffy was even in its bumpy opening season, there are enough elements in common to justify a tenuous comparison and enough small pleasures to encourage continued viewing.