There are no new explanations here, just a better packaged version of what Anno already delivered, which makes You Are (Not) Alone very attractive but fundamentally pointless.
What are people saying?
What are critics saying?
As a visceral experience, it’s entrancing, especially during Shinji’s fight sequences, when his anxieties are cruelly exacerbated by having his body and mind symbiotically bonded to his father’s combat toy.
Los Angeles Times by Kevin Thomas
The story possesses a true depth of character; there is every reason to hope that Anno’s multiple meanings become increasingly clear in the subsequent installments.
The New York Times by Mike Hale
When the material is condensed, nearly everything that made the first two-thirds of the television series distinctive _ the deliberate pace, the wry humor, the subtle (for anime) characterizations is lost. “Evangelion” becomes just another giant-robot story.