A State of Mind | Telescope Film
A State of Mind

A State of Mind

Critic Rating

(read reviews)

User Rating

Two young North Korean gymnasts prepare for a competition in this documentary that offers a rare look into the daily lives of North Korean families. Over the course of eight months, A State of Mind follows 13-year-old Pak Hyon Sun and 11-year-old Kim Song Yun as they train for the Mass Games, a spectacular nationalist celebration.

Stream A State of Mind

What are critics saying?

75

New York Daily News by Elizabeth Weitzman

Despite the obvious cultural differences, what we come away with is a surprising sense of familiarity. Not even the widest political chasms, Gordon finds, can eradicate the universal pleasure of a young girl's giggle.

75

New York Post by V.A. Musetto

Has two especially memorable sequences: the eye-popping Mass Games and a visit by a group of schoolgirls to incredibly beautiful Mount Paekdu, which is revered by Koreans on both sides of the DMZ.

75

Seattle Post-Intelligencer by William Arnold

Subtly suggests it may not be all that much different from the delusions by which other cultures are structured.

75

Boston Globe by Ty Burr

It's a quietly wrenching eye-opener.

70

Wall Street Journal

The girls' enormous appeal prevents the political subtext from overburdening the film.

70

L.A. Weekly by Paul Malcolm

The stadiums and performance halls of Pyongyang become staging grounds for massive, highly choreographed political pageants that make the Nuremberg rallies look like dinner theater. You’ve never seen anything quite like these dazzling displays of groupthink.

70

TV Guide Magazine by Ken Fox

Most mystifying, however, is the bizarre hero-worship surrounding the fingure of Kim Jong Il, a nationwide personality cult that makes Joe Stalin and Chairman Mao look like D-list celebrities.

70

The Hollywood Reporter by Richard James Havis

Certainly should appeal to viewers with an interest in current affairs.

70

Los Angeles Times by Kevin Crust

The result is a fresh, straightforward portrayal of what the film calls "the least visible ... least known ... least understood ... country in the world."

70

Wall Street Journal by Jim Fusilli

The girls' enormous appeal prevents the political subtext from overburdening the film.

60

The A.V. Club by Noel Murray

Beautifully shot and crisply edited to emphasize the Mass Games' pageantry, but amid the synchronized blocks of performers, Gordon singles out the cranky coaches and giggling schoolgirls, subtly emphasizing how the individual endures even when she's trying hard not to.

60

Village Voice by Ed Park

One leaves the film with the Twilight Zone sense that the place isn't quite the hellhole prior reports have suggested.

60

Variety by Derek Elley

Admirably non-judgmental docu about life in "the least visited, known, understood country in the world," per Brit director Daniel Gordon, brings a refreshing balance to the usual blind vilification of the country.

50

San Francisco Chronicle

Although the documentary is ostensibly about these girls and their friendship, training and school life, a healthy chunk of it is a portrait of the two families.

50

The New York Times by Lawrence Van Gelder

A rare and often chilling glimpse into the culture of North Korea.