Machines | Telescope Film
Machines

Machines

Critic Rating

(read reviews)

User Rating

  • India,
  • Germany,
  • Finland
  • 2017
  • · 71m

Director Rahul Jain
Genre Documentary

This portrayal of the rhythm of life and work in a gigantic textile factory in Gujarat, India, moves through the corridors and bowels of the enormously disorienting structure — taking the viewer on a journey of dehumanizing physical labor and intense hardship.

Stream Machines

What are critics saying?

100

Village Voice by Aaron Hillis

Machines proves both uncompromising and unforgettable.

90

Variety by Guy Lodge

This simultaneously beautiful and abjectly unhappy film is forced to close by silently admitting its limitations.

80

The Hollywood Reporter by Neil Young

Showing levels of controlled concentration and unfussy flair far beyond what may be expected from a "student film," Machines powerfully evokes the sights and sounds — and almost even the smells — of a sprawling, stygian textiles plant south of India's eighth-largest (but very seldom filmed) city, Surat.

80

The Guardian by Peter Bradshaw

A sombre, relevant piece of work.

80

Total Film by Matt Looker

While their situation feels futile, the film is almost poetic in posing important questions.

80

Time Out London by Trevor Johnston

Some accuse the filmmaker of being just like the politicians who turn up, look around and do nothing. It adds a confrontational edge to the film’s already startling combination of immersive aesthetics and humane empathy.

80

Los Angeles Times by Robert Abele

It never succumbs to making poverty a graphic ornament.

75

IndieWire by David Ehrlich

A spare and unflinching documentary about the true cost of cheap textiles, Machines doesn’t tell us anything we don’t already know about the inhumane work conditions in countries like India, but it forces us to become palpably familiar with the awful facts of the matter.

75

Slant Magazine by Kenji Fujishima

Rahul Jain’s film conveys with revelatory force the mechanization of people in an industrialized milieu.

60

The New York Times by Ben Kenigsberg

The ideological charge leveled for decades at this strain of filmmaking is that such eye-catching tableaus romanticize poverty, but prettified squalor has become sadly familiar in global documentary filmmaking. In Machines, even at barely more than an hour, the style leads to diminishing returns.

50

RogerEbert.com by Godfrey Cheshire

A film so obedient to current academic fashions in both politics and cinema aesthetics that it ends up feeling both contrived and a bit dishonest.