30
Village Voice by Alan Scherstuhl
The story feels shapeless, un-tailored, defiantly off the rack.
What are people saying?
What are critics saying?
67
Entertainment Weekly by Chris Nashawaty
While it's breezy and funny and perfectly pleasant, you probably won't remember this particular gift by the time the next birthday rolls around.
50
Slant Magazine by David Lee Dallas
A film of obvious characterizations and even more obvious plot machinations that render its moment-to-moment charms moot.
58
Magic in the Moonlight belongs to the pool of lesser Allen comedies, yet Firth and Emma Stone — as the alleged necromancer Sophie Baker, the object of Stanley's scrutiny and eventually his affections — bring all the zany energy they can muster.
20
Emma Stone couldn't be more charming, but her on-screen romance with Colin Firth couldn't be more contrived or ickiliy age-inappropriate.
83
This picture isn’t as showy or obvious as one of his (many) masterpieces, but it is quite good and deserves your time and respect.
80
The director’s latest—a lighthearted romance set in 1920s Germany and France—won’t do much to sway proponents or detractors from their own perspectives, though taken at face value, it’s one of Allen’s most charmingly conceived and performed efforts.
75
Magic In The Moonlight is good in many regards, and mostly enjoyable for most of its 97 minute running time. But it’s also admittedly uneven in spots, familiar and ultimately a bit slight.
80
Whenever Firth and Stone are onscreen together, the movie sings; the rest of the time it’s never less than a breezy divertissement.
40
The Hollywood Reporter by Todd McCarthy
Magic in the Moonlight does have a not-disagreeable expensive-vacation vibe to it. But the one-dimensional characters are mostly ones you’d want to avoid rather than spend a holiday with.