67
Paste Magazine by Aurora Amidon
Despite the documentary’s scattered approach, it’s not exactly a chore to take interest in the backstory of such an iconic moment in American cultural history.
What are people saying?
What are critics saying?
60
The New York Times by Glenn Kenny
The movie really comes alive when it is recreating the recording session for the song, showing how the ace studio keyboardist Paul Griffin transformed the tune with his energetic gospel-style piano.
50
Wall Street Journal by John Anderson
For all the gushing about the “transcendent” nature of “American Pie,” Mr. Brooks is the one who actually mentions, and praises, the recording itself, which becomes a fascinating aspect to a show that seems to spend an inordinate amount of time justifying its existence.
60
Los Angeles Times by Noel Murray
Somehow, the more McLean explains the song, the more wondrous it seems.