80
The Dancer Upstairs, is a haunting and often beautiful work, part doomed romance and part political thriller, that demonstrates the adult command of the medium Malkovich has always demonstrated as an actor.
What are people saying?
What are critics saying?
80
The film has a foggy cast to it--flat and insinuatingly creepy, like the actor. But then it can be lit, in an instant, by searing flash-pots of cruelty and wit. Even when it's slightly opaque, it's transfixing.
63
The Globe and Mail (Toronto) by Liam Lacey
The movie is often both smart and creepy, but it's still a novice effort. After an initially engrossing start, it stumbles through a series of implausible coincidences and murky events, barely held together by the magnetic performance of Javier Bardem.
40
Austin Chronicle by Marc Savlov
Falters in small but important ways -– the suspense, carefully ratcheted up throughout, just plain goes busto in the film’s final moments -– while Malkovich stays resolutely behind the camera, a consummate professional who, this time, misses his mark by the merest of degrees.
63
Chicago Tribune by Michael Wilmington
A promising film rather than a fully realized one.
75
It has an elusive, haunting quality, but it's too long at 133 minutes, and there aren't many movies these days that get more involving as they progress.
83
Entertainment Weekly by Owen Gleiberman
The movie has a mystery, and moral unease, that lingers.
70
New York Magazine (Vulture) by Peter Rainer
At its best in the interludes between explosions.
90
Patient and plodding -- but as realized by John Malkovich, in his directorial debut, utterly absorbing.
63
Far from perfect but completely unique, the film could best be described as a paranoid South American metaphysical political thriller -- you heard me -- and whatever its failures, they're not ones of nerve or imagination.